TED’S SOAP BOX    This is a new addition to my web-site – a sounding board where I can let off steam. For instance:

A.     Most of the questions I am asked and also appearing on Facebook, Hoya 101, etc. have already been answered in my articles in Fraterna (the old Hoya magazine) as:David Silverman's DS-70 =  Hoya tsangii, Burton.  SO, I am going to use material from several. All of this right here in River City!   

And, it might be of interest of those who haven't been lucky enough to  travel and collected as I have in the past 40 years - so I will talk about some of my trips.  This is a series and I will add things each time I update this website.

WHERE I FIRST  COLLECTED CERTAIN SPECIES:

Hoya danumensis was a scrambling vine growing in a dry clump of small trees and bushes just outside of the Danum  Valley preserve (close to Lahad Datu) in Sabah, Malaysia,  The plant was not in flower but I guessed that it was either a  Hoya or a close relative - opposite, paired leaves, milky sap, etc.  This area was forested  with a reforested Acacia and it was obvious that elephants had stripped the sweet  bark.  There were piles of dung from the elephants.

HOYA BLOOMING?

How long do you have to wait for an established  cutting to bloom? Some flower within 6 months of collection (a very rare rarity), most bloom within a year,  and would  you believe, that some have not bloomed in 8 to 10 years.  My conditions are near perfect and I think that my plants have the best of conditions so I don't know  the reasons for some not flowering early and regularly.  Hoya imperialis alba and "Palawan" fall in that category.   Contrarily, on my sunny front  porch I have H affinis that I collected in 1976 on the Island of Tulagi (by Guadalcanal) and it started to bloom within a year and has  bloomed regularly for the past 40 years.

Some clones of Hoya chlorantha, Hoya imperialis Palawan, and imperialis alba are temperamental and do not flower regularly..

I have found that H. mappigera, the form from Peninsular Malaysia,  that first flowered in 6 months, now flowers continuously -  hanging from the eave of our house - in 75% sunlight.

B.     About  Dale Klopppenburg:

Dale is my oldest friend. We grew up together in Fresno, California and had the same interests of flying, tropical fish, orchids, traveling and collecting, tissue culture and the US Navy. He is a graduate of the University of California Berkeley with a degree in Genetics.  Upon graduation, he (and I) both worked on fig research for the Cal Fig Institute and then parted ways - he, to rose hybridization and fruit development at Armstrong Nursery and I, to the USDA.  

As a prolific writer, he started out with simple articles and authored books on Hoya growing.  As he became more knowledgeable of the genus Hoya: by studying at the National Herbarium in Manila, his association with people at the University of the Philippines, Los Banos (UPLB) and many trips to the Philippines, his interest increased to book publication and the publication of Philippine species of Hoya.  

The publication of new species started with the material collected by the staff at the UPLB and expanded to include Philippine private and commercial grower/collectors, who asked for help.  The live material was grown at the UPLB, herbarium sheets and drawing were done by students and deposited in Philippine herbaria.  Later, some herbarium sheets were produced and deposited at the UC Berkeley herbarium or by me, here in Hawaii and deposited at the Bishop Museum.   

Dale has not collected or grown Hoyas for many years and his determinations have been from the liquid specimens and photos sent to him. He has looked at least 400 specimens and seeing so many he has become very critical of differences.  It is a fact, he is a “splitter” but still adheres to the adage:  1 difference from the type makes it a variety; 2, a subspecies: and 3, a new species.  

Right now, he is still way behind in determining the many specimens sent to him but still is finding time to work on an atlas of hoya pollinia.  And, complaining that there is no one to make the herbarium sheets in in the Philippines, at UPLB.

C.     There are 2 types of taxonomist:  the lumper, who considers the type, its varieties and subspecies – as the species; whereas, the splitter will divide the type into subspecies and varietiesas I state above. Personally, I am a lumper and accept the broad variations that occur within a species.

The average hobbyist does not even see or notice the naked-eye characters (leaf venation, the gland, etc.), let alone the tiny variations (pollinia, etc.) that can be seen only with a microscope.  The hobbyist thinks the tiny differences are incidental.  The taxonomist thinks that they are extremely important in describing a new species.  I contend that species must differ in at least 3 characters, with color not being one of them, to be valid. And, even then, I believe that there must be at least 2,000 species of Hoyas. Every time we go collecting we find plants that we might consider a new species. But, it is only my opinion. Dale has a different opinion: I've always said we have only collected in about 1% of the area and so 2000 is my guess as to the number of species. I think we can walk right by a new species that is on the other side of a tree, and who gets off the trails, streams, roads or ridges?. Very seldom, and vast areas in between are untouched by a collector”. 

The average hobbyist is more aware of color, fragrance, length of blooming time, and general overall appearance - all things that are usually not considered by the taxonomist.

There is no final authority to settle arguments between hobbyists, between hobbyist and taxonomist or even between taxonomists.  Many times it is personal interpretation and personal opinion!

 D.    I have found that there is a group of new collectors who want the the latest and rarest species - with money being no object.  I suggest they they study and find out how to start new cuttings and specifically about those new ones for it breaks my heart to hear back that they have lost some very rare things we sent them. In some cases it is experimenting with different ways of trying to root them.

E.    I usually take people at their word and give them the benefit of the doubt. For instance, if they tell me that a shipment arrived in good condition and then 6 months later ask for a replacement of ones that have died, I get suspicious - especially, if I find out later that the cuttings were placed in a closed plastic bag. They claim that the shipment was of rotting plants.  Would you believe the first statement or the last?

F.     Since 1998 when Dale Kloppenburg published it in Fraterna (based on my herbarium specimen), I have used the name "odetteae" for the handsome little thing from the Philippines that was named to honor Odette Cumming,  wife of David Cumming (friends of mine), whom I have collected  with.  Now, someone pointed out that Chris Burton made a mistake in naming H. tsangii by citing the wrong herbarium sheet (H. angustifolia) and as a result gave it the name "odetteae" - how and why I will never know! This gets better, the one that I have always called H tsangii, with the dark fuzzy leaves and red flowers, is the one I am sure that Chris Burton meant to be tsangii.  I don't think that David Silverman or Odette would be happy and Peter Tsang  is turning over in his grave - I know that I am not happy. Should I tell Odette?  If you understand all this explain it to me. Until the dust settles, I am going to continue to list my plants as I always have - angustifolia, tsangii and odetteae for they are all different.   

G.    Many people ask what our nursery looks like. They think that we have a proper nursery with greenhouses - isn't so! - just our home with a jungle around it - weeds, mosquitoes and tons of hoyas, orchids and other plants. We are about 4 blocks from the beach and at an elevation of about 100 ft. (up against the mountain) in the tiny village of Kaaawa (named after a reef fish), and is pronounced Ka, aa, ava (all as are flat sounding). Here are some pictures from front of the house, left and on around the house. 2 of the cars are ours - the rest are visitors. Bill collectors?

            

H.           I have seen comments and arguments about some of my plants. I have later found out that in some cases the plant in question is not the one that I originally distributed.  I have bought or traded to get back a plant that I have lost and then found out what was sent to me was not the correct thing!  Where did the correct labeling go astray? Think of the trouble and hard feelings that causes!

I.                 Or, in an attempt to capitalize on a new plant that I distributed, a new trade name has been dreamed up and the country of origin changed, as the “Funnel Hoya” that is from Sabah, Malaysia, not Papua New Guinea.  The correct name of this species is Hoya lambii which I named after my friend Tony Lamb of Kota Kinabalu, Sabah.

J.        Hoya collecting should be enjoyable, a pleasure. Just because the several camps disagree over the exact scientific names of several Hoyas doesn’t mean that there should be such mean spirited and vituperative people to ruin the Hoya world!  A grower once told me that Hoya collectors are the most disputatious in the plant world!  As a famous black philosopher once said: Why can’t we all just get along?

K.    PLANT COLLECTING and PERMITS

    Dale Kloppenburg and I have been working with Hoyas, for our simple pleasure and the scientific interest, for over 35 years. It has been very interesting and enjoyable – collecting the literature and collecting and comparing the plants, that have come from both the wilds and other’s collections. We have shared the knowledge we have gained by publishing it in books, in horticultural articles and talks to garden clubs and hoya societies around the world. It has always been pleasurable, a two-way street, enjoyed by many.

    Now, a serious problem has developed, one caused by the U. S. Department of Agriculture, that is changing all of that. The USDA is now insisting that all plants and plant materials entering the U.S. must be accompanied by a Phytosanitary Certificate from the exporting country. The intent, to quote the USDA, being "to prevent the introduction of plant pests, diseases, and noxious weeds not known to occur here".

    If all of the countries, where Hoyas grow wild, were sophisticated (with trained personnel, various offices, and a organized work ethic) that would be wonderful BUT the reality is that they are not. Many of the countries where I have collected are not set up to issue permits, anywhere other than the capital city. The permit might be obtained only to collect a fee and then only after confusion and delays (which are both expensive). This can easily amount to $100 for $10 worth of plants.

    It is understandable that an individual country should have the right to establish a conservation program, both for the plant material and intellectual property, but many of the unsophisticated countries have been unduly influenced by the U. S. and U. K. governments. The sharing of conservation tracts has awakened them to, not necessarily to saving species, but a new way to make money – permit selling. Though Hoyas are not covered by CITES, thank God!, if they were that would be another turnstile with a toll. CITES controlled plants (as, Orchids, Nepenthes, etc.) must all be accompanied by a Phyto.

    Dale and I found out another tollgate while in Vanuatu in 2001. Upon asking for a Phyto in the second largest town (which is on Espiritu Santo), we were told that we could get it only in the capital, Port Vila on Efate (175 miles away). When we contacted Port Vila, they asked why we hadn’t applied for a "Collecting Permit" before we entered the county? Interestingly, in that permit we would have had to enumerate the species and number we wanted to collect! Who knows what you are going to find – hopefully, a new species or two? This permit system idea is now getting to be quite common and has been "improved upon" to the point where some countries insist that a "team" (with all its expenses) accompany you in your collecting. That team might consist of a representative of the government and a district tribal member.

     Typically, branches of government seem to be working a odds with each other: Conservation vs. Forestry vs. Transportation vs. Commerce; as in Sabah where logging is licensed (under Forestry) and yet the plants growing on the trees are protected (under Conservation). Or as, in 2000 a conservation conference was held on Palawan in the Philippines, (with signs everywhere) and yet I saw hundreds of acres of plants being destroyed to widen a new highway north from Puerto Princesa, toward Sabang. The extensive over-clearing for the right-of-way was a disaster!

L.     It was pointed out to me, from a comment by a lady in one of the Hoya Chat Rooms, the size of the cuttings that I offer are small.  Come to find out, I did not sell the items to her but to another person who proceeded to cut them in half and share, sell or trade to the complainer.  I think that this is a reason why some do not ask for replacements - for I ask that the whole dead material be returned, as sent.  That is impossible to do if they have been cut up and the half sold or traded off. 

M.        ORCHIDS IN HAWAII

    What started out to be my book for tourists in Hawaii has been reconsidered for general distribution and to reach a greater audience.  This is a different orchid book.  It is NOT a book about growing orchids but where they can be found in Hawaii, recognizing orchids, orchid science, reading labels, nurseries, clubs, meetings, shows, choosing and buying plants, etc. 128 pages, all in color.- even the fly and the ant on the cover!

    This book is listed at about $10.95 and is available at garden shops and book stores across the country, AOS Book Store, or from the publisher: www.mutualpublishing.com

 

Revised 20 Septemberl 2016

Home ] Introduction to Prices and Shipping ] Hoya Catalog ] Ted’s Soap Box ] Order Page ] Orchid List ] [ Publications ]

[bottom.htm]